Ken Borland

The two yellow cards in the Sharks versus Bulls Currie Cup match last weekend in Durban have caused much comment but, in my opinion, if rugby is going to continue to be officiated in that fashion then the sport itself is going to be fundamentally altered, alienating both fans and players.

Both Sharks centre Marius Louw and Bulls prop Jacques van Rooyen were yellow-carded for tackles which made contact to the head of their opponent. The head is now an extremely touchy subject in the sport given WorldRugby’s efforts to avoid future mega-millions law suits as we have seen in gridiron, but they were the sort of incidents that are going to happen numerous times in any game of rugby.

Rugby is a collision sport, it’s all about the gain-line now, there are going to be clashes of heads and it’s a bit like expecting a boxer not to be hit on the head. With some sports, there are just inherent risks that come with the game and are accepted by the participants: boxers are going to get hit in the face, formula one drivers are going to crash and rugby players are going to clash heads.

If rugby’s rule-makers are going to continue with their clampdown then the game will be changed and not necessarily for the good of the spectators, who are the people who pay the money that keeps the professional game afloat and pays the salaries of those administrators constantly tinkering with the laws.

As tacklers are forced to go lower and lower, rugby will become a sport dominated by attack, more like Sevens. Players will be able to offload at will, making for a much faster, less physical game. Which will then lead to coaches choosing quicker, more endurance-type athletes rather than those with power. It will be the end of the big strong guys in the tight five and rugby will have lost its unique selling point as a game for all shapes and sizes. As Duane Vermeulen said, we might as well just go and play ‘touchies’ – touch rugby, where no tackling is allowed.

Of course concussion and related head injuries are an issue in rugby and we are not going to encourage parents to let their children play the game unless it is going to be safe, or as safe as it can reasonably be made. It is all about risk management.

From that perspective, rules to clamp down on any foul or reckless act that leads to the head being targeted are most welcome. Things like shoulder-to-head or boot-to-head should absolutely be – pardon the expression – stamped out. But if every single incident of contact to the head is to be penalised with a card then we’re not going to have many players left on the field and games are going to be ruined.

In a World Cup final, are the tackles of Louw and Van Rooyen really going to be dealt with in the same way? I am inclined to think referee Marius van der Westhuizen only picked up on the incidents because Morne Steyn went down after Louw’s tackle and Van Rooyen left the field due to bleeding after his head clash with Venter. Van der Westhuizen’s comment to the TMO (who he later overruled anyway) that they should start at the high end of punishment and then work their way lower was also absurd.

The actions of the ball-carrier also have a great influence on the tackle as a whole. If they duck down and go in head first, much like Venter did, then the likelihood of being hit on the head is so much higher; it’s almost unfair on the defender to expect them, at the last second, to somehow get underneath the attacker to stop them.

Acts of foul play or recklessness must absolutely be dealt with harshly if it leads to a head injury, but the current interpretation our referees are using is going to lead to a major final being decided by the softest of moments when a player has unintentionally erred in tackling the way he was taught all those years ago when he started playing the game.

The log-leading Bulls may have had the disappointment of having their Currie Cup game this weekend cancelled due to Covid-19, but the Sharks are having to take on the Lions at Ellis Park on Saturday with four of their tight five missing.

Hooker Dan Jooste and lock Ruben van Heerden have both tested positive for Covid-19, while tighthead prop Thomas du Toit has a rib injury and lock Hyron Andrews is missing for personal reasons. Michael Kumbirai will hopefully pick up from where he left off as Du Toit’s replacement last weekend, while hooker Kerron van Vuuren and lock JJ van der Mescht have both featured in the starting line-up already this season so their promotions are no big deal.

Aston Fortuin meanwhile, is a former Bulls lock and will make his debut for the Sharks in the No.5 jersey, replacing Andrews, who is unavailable due to a family bereavement.

“These sort of changes are always disruptive and Ruben, Hyron and Thomas have all been playing really good rugby, while Dan was outstanding last weekend. But JJ has had game time, it’s going to be exciting for Aston coming in next to him, Michael is back from his heroics last weekend and Kerron obviously comes in as well. It’s a nice opportunity for the guys, but they have had game time before.

“Travelling while there is so much Covid around is a concern and this weekend is a challenge because we don’t know who will be with us on the aeroplane to Johannesburg or who will be with us in the hotel. To play the Cheetahs in Bloemfontein next week we will be chartering our own flight, which means you spend a lot less time at the airport, but this weekend we just have to make sure the guys adhere to the protocols,” Sharks coach Sean Everitt said on Thursday.

Despite losing four tight forwards, Everitt has once again gone with a 6-2 split on the bench due to the expected heavy conditions at altitude.

“We know there could be showers at some stage, so it’s going to be a heavy field and it’s difficult playing on the highveld anyway, that’s why we’ve gone with a 6-2 bench. It is a 7pm kickoff though so fortunately we won’t be in the highveld sun. But we enjoy playing ball-in-hand and some of our best rugby has been played away from home. So hopefully it will be a dry ball.

“I wanted to reward the performance over the Bulls as well and ensure some continuity, but apart from needing speed around the field against the Lions at Ellis Park, we’re going to need fresh legs for the last 30 minutes because that is when the Lions score most of their tries,” Everitt said.

Sharks – Manie Libbok, Sbu Nkosi, Lukhanyo Am (capt), Marius Louw, Yaw Penxe, Curwin Bosch, Sanele Nohamba, Sikhumbuzo Notshe, Henco Venter, Dylan Richardson, Aston Fortuin, JJ van der Mescht, Michael Kumbirai, Kerron van Vuuren, Ox Nche. Bench: Fez Mbatha, Mzamo Majola, John-Hubert Meyer, Thembelani Bholi, James Venter, Phepsi Buthelezi, Jaden Hendrikse, Jeremy Ward.

It’s been a tough week in the office for Bulls CEO Edgar Rathbone, with positive Covid tests materialising on Tuesday and their Currie Cup match against Griquas this weekend in Kimberley called off on Thursday due to the spread of the virus within the Bulls squad and management.

“It’s unfortunate that it has hit us now, but to be honest it was probably to be expected somewhere down the line. We had a few positives on Tuesday, which meant re-tests on Wednesday and that threw up additional cases and the game had to be cancelled. The numbers are not important but obviously they are substantial enough for the NICD to call the match off.

“Fortunately we did not train on Monday or Tuesday so that limited the risk of the spread. But for 10 days the infected must be isolated. We will have further tests on Monday morning and then we will make a call on the following week only after that. So at the moment it’s tough to say whether we can play the Lions on Boxing Day. If the virus has infiltrated the front row then things become more complicated,” Rathbone said on Thursday.

It seems inevitable that when the Bulls do get back on to the park, they will have to complete their Currie Cup charge with a weakened team. The two points from the cancelled Griquas game – when they might have expected five – means the Sharks will close to within two points with a game in hand if they beat the Lions with a bonus point on Saturday.

“We need to trust our squad depth and I believe only a number of infections in the front row could possibly make it impossible for us to fulfil fixtures. Obviously the team are disappointed not to be playing this weekend. but there are mixed feelings because they are obviously also concerned over their team-mates’ well-being because unfortunately a few of them are showing some symptoms.

“But the Griquas match had to be cancelled as a draw because if you look at the calendar and the number of weeks left it’s very difficult to find a space to postpone the game to. And we have to be consistent and keep parity between the teams who have also had fixtures called off,” Rathbone said.

The Bulls have enjoyed one of the longer occupancies at the top of the local rugby log this season and it has been the sort of success which could lead to complacency. Which is why hooker Johan Grobbelaar said on Wednesday that the narrow loss to the Sharks last weekend has given them the opportunity to look more closely at what they are doing before the knockout rounds begin on January 15.

The Bulls still enjoy a five-point lead at the top of the Currie Cup log, but one more slip-up and the Sharks could catch them, so the Durban defeat has been a timely reminder that nothing is assured yet.

“We’ve had a good run and we are still in a good position. You are always going to make some mistakes in every game, but last weekend has forced us to look at ourselves, it has forced us to look at our game a bit deeper and it will make sure we don’t get too comfortable. There’s never a right time to lose, but rather now than in the knockout rounds.

“It’s given us a good chance to look at our mistakes, but our preparation this week has been more or less the same as previously. It’s important that we don’t try and make massive changes, we need to stick to the things that have worked for us. Like our lineout is still good, we don’t have to be too worried about that and we still want to make it a physical battle against Griquas in Kimberley on Saturday,” Grobbelaar said on Wednesday.

Playing brilliant, freeflowing attacking rugby is not always that easy in the mid-summer heat and at Tafel Lager Park on Saturday, with the temperature expected to be in the mid-30s even at their 4.30pm kickoff time, there are going to be mistakes made my tired bodies as the game progresses.

“Playing in Kimberley is not that big a problem for me because I come from Paarl where it gets really hot, and we train in a lot of heat in Pretoria. But the high temperature does make a difference, it means there’s extra sweat all over the ball and your jerseys are wet as well. So the ball becomes more slippery and that leads to more knock-ons.

“It means we have to take on more fluids and the game is possibly a bit slower because there are more mistakes. But apart from that, for every away game we try to make things as comfortable as possible. Playing Griquas is always tough and you can never underestimate them, they beat us here at Loftus last year and at the beginning of the season they gave us a tough game here as well,” Grobbelaar said.