Ken Borland

Each highly successful Test team through the ages has had their specific formula for success  – think the West Indies and their fast bowlers or Australia and their aggressive batsmen setting the platform for Warne and McGrath to wheel away – and the current Proteas have always insisted that playing seven specialist batsmen has been a key factor in their climb to number one in the rankings.

But that philosophy may came under threat at SuperSport Park today when the first Test against the West Indies gets underway.

That’s largely due to the absence of the injured JP Duminy, which affects the balance of the Test side almost as much as the ODI outfit. An all-pace attack and seven specialist batsmen has been possible with Duminy there to bowl his tidy off-spin, but without him the options are either to have three pacemen and Robin Peterson, four quicks and no spinner save for Dean Elgar, or to go in with six specialist batsmen and play both the extra fast bowler and Peterson.

Although the seamers do traditionally bowl the bulk of the overs in Centurion, there have been occasions in the last five years when South Africa have relied heavily on spin – in both innings against Australia last season (22 and 31% of the overs bowled); in the second innings against India in 2010/11 (23%) and in both innings against England in 2009/10 (38 and 35%).

So there will be a reluctance to go into the Test, despite the rain around Gauteng on Tuesday and however grassy the pitch may be on the first day, without a specialist spinner.

“There might be a cracking blue sky at the game tomorrow so we’re not sure what our combination will be. We’ll see what happens on the day,” was all Hashim Amla, who will captain South Africa for the first time in a home Test, was willing to offer on Tuesday.

AB de Villiers was a bit more forthcoming, however.

“It’s the biggest decision management will have to make,” De Villiers said. “Centurion normally doesn’t turn that much which makes you feel that you can maybe go with that extra seamer, but with the team we are playing against, it might not be a bad idea to play a spinner. I’m pretty sure management will be tempted to play an all-pace attack though.”

For Dale Steyn, an extra batsman was important, despite the extra workload that would place on the stalwart fast bowler.

“It can be a bit sporty on day one, a bit slow, the last time we played here against Australia was crazy because it went up and down, but then in previous Tests it flattened out,” he said. “It was hard work to bowl teams out. Our batsmen were very dominant so it gave us enough time.”

The last time South Africa played the West Indies at SuperSport Park – in January 2004 – the tourists were tenderised by an opening stand of 301 between Graeme Smith and Herschelle Gibbs, followed by a Jacques Kallis century. Makhaya Ntini then took eight wickets in the match as the follow-on was enforced, resulting in a 10-wicket victory. Part-timers Smith and Jacques Rudolph were the Proteas’ spinners, bowling just 19.4 overs in the Test.

Steyn wasn’t quite laughing when he said: “I don’t think it really matters whether we play the spinner or the seamer, I think we’ll still do okay” – but the formbook and history both suggest the West Indies should be outclassed.

They are a formidable limited-overs outfit, but targeting cow-corner doesn’t often work as a strategy in Test cricket and few people will stake a fortune on the West Indies winning. One well-known bookmaker is offering odds of 1/33 that South Africa will win if there is a result in the match.

Even West Indies captain Denesh Ramdin was not sounding hugely confident on Tuesday.

“It’s going to be very challenging, we’re up against the number one team so they must be doing something very good to be on top, plus they’re at home. We need to be more consistent, especially our batting which has not been up to scratch lately. In the field we need to minimise our mistakes, not bowl so many bad balls and make sure our slip catching is up to par. If we perform well against the number one team, we should get credit for that. We will take it one step at a time and do our best,” Ramdin said.

While the West Indies are an inexperienced team with seven of their squad having played less than 10 Tests, South Africa will have just one greenhorn in action.

Stiaan van Zyl has staked his claim for a Test berth with a Sunfoil Series average of 49.57 and Amla admitted there was “a very good chance” of him playing, although he won’t bat at seven.

Let’s hope the silky strokeplay of the left-hander is employed at number six – specialist batsmen need to have the responsibility of batting in the top six – with wicketkeeper Quinton de Kock at seven.

There is speculation, however, that Van Zyl might replace Alviro Petersen at the top of the order, thereby enabling South Africa to play four pacemen and a spinner, with Vernon Philander batting at seven.

Petersen has put himself in the firing line by not exactly scoring a keg-full of runs lately, with just one half-century in his last 10 innings, and he has yet to play any four-day cricket for the Highveld Lions this season.

Squads

South Africa: Alviro Petersen, Dean Elgar, Faf du Plessis, Hashim Amla, AB de Villiers, Stiaan van Zyl, Quinton de Kock, Vernon Philander, Robin Peterson, Dale Steyn, Morne Morkel, Kyle Abbott, Temba Bavuma, Kagiso Rabada.

West Indies: Kraigg Brathwaite, Devon Smith, Leon Johnson, Marlon Samuels, Shivnarine Chanderpaul, Jason Holder, Denesh Ramdin, Jerome Taylor, Kemar Roach, Sheldon Cottrell, Sulieman Benn, Shannon Gabriel, Asad Fudadin, Jermaine Blackwood, Chadwick Walton.

Ian Bell laid the platform as England beat South Africa by six wickets in the fourth NatWest One-Day International at Lord’s on Sunday to seal the number one ranking for the rest of the year.

47th over – Dale Steyn has switched ends but his first ball from the Pavilion End is a nothing delivery, short outside off, and Craig Kieswetter stands tall and swats it through midwicket for four. A wide bouncer and a top-edged four over the wicketkeeper follow, before Kieswetter ends the match in style with a magnificent straight drive for six.

46th over – Ryan McLaren drags a slower ball halfway down the pitch and Eoin Morgan pulls it fine for four. Three balls later, Morgan swats the seamer over mid-on for a one-bounce four and then hooks the last ball of the over, a bouncer, fine for four.

45th over – Wayne Parnell allows Kieswetter to free his arms and he drives majestically through the covers for four.

44th over – WICKET – Bell advances down the pitch at Steyn, who bangs the ball in short. There is good bounce and Bell can only edge his slash at the ball, wicketkeeper AB de Villiers leaping to take a one-handed catch. Bell’s 88 off 137 balls, with eight fours and a six, was a great innings though and should have done enough to win the game for England.

42nd over – Too short from Robin Peterson and Morgan pulls with tremendous power and timing for four.

38th over – Super batting by Morgan as he skips down the pitch and clips McLaren straight down the ground for four.

36th over – WICKET – Ravi Bopara fails again, pushing at a delivery outside off stump from McLaren and sending a low edge to wicketkeeper De Villiers. Bopara is out for six.

35th over – Steyn returns but can only bowl one delivery before a 16-minute rain delay. His second ball after the resumption of play is short and outside off stump and Bopara pulls it to mid-on, where it bounces just before Lonwabo Tsotsobe and zips past him off the wet grass for four runs.

33rd over – Tsotsobe produces a horrible long-hop down the leg side which Bell flicks away disdainfully for four runs.

32nd over – WICKET – Trott tries to sweep left-arm spinner Dean Elgar but the delivery is too full and is struck low on the front pad. Umpire Simon Taufel turns down the lbw appeal, but South Africa call for a review and it shows it’s plumb! Trott goes for a gutsy 48 off 77 balls – most of the innings played with one hand because of the fierce blow he received from Steyn.

31st over – Dropped! Bell, on 65, mistimes a lofted drive at a Tsotsobe slower ball but Peterson at deep mid-on misjudges the catch, is leaping and drops the ball! The next ball is short and Bell hammers a pull through midwicket for four.

29th over – Tsotsobe is back and Bell is down the pitch again and a lovely lofted straight drive brings him four more runs.

25th over – Steyn returns as South Africa desperately need a breakthrough. But their only slip is at about third slip and Bell half-steers/half-edges the ball in the gap between the wicketkeeper and slip for another boundary!

23rd over – The hundred is up off 134 balls as Trott steps outside off stump and flicks McLaren high over midwicket for four.

20th over – A magnificent stroke by Bell as he comes down the pitch and drives Peterson elegantly over extra cover for six.

19th over – Bell hops down the pitch, Parnell drops the ball shorter and is slapped over cover for four.

17th over – Too full and wide from Parnell and Bell drives sumptiously through extra cover for four.

10th over – Bell now comes down the wicket and pulls McLaren powerfully through wide mid-on for four.

9th over – Another commanding stroke by Trott as he comes down the pitch to Tsotsobe and cuts him imperiously over point for four.

8th over – Another wonderful shot by Trott as McLaren angles a delivery into him and he drives it sweetly through midwicket for four.

3rd over – Trott is off the mark in wonderful fashion as he steps forward confidently and square-drives Steyn on the up through point for four.

1st over – WICKET – Steyn ends a fine first over with a vital breakthrough. Alastair Cook steps across his stumps and is beaten by a great delivery that swings back into the left-hander, trapping him lbw for two.

South Africa innings

It was hardly a batting feast for South Africa as they struggled to 220 for eight against England in the fourth NatWest One-Day International at Lord’s in London on Sunday.

49th over – WICKET – Dean Elgar’s struggle is over as he gloves a hook at a slower-ball bouncer from Jade Dernbach and is caught behind by Craig Kieswetter for 35 off 59 balls, with just a single boundary.

48th over – Super batting by Robin Peterson as he picks up Dernbach’s slower ball and heaves it to cow-corner for a one-bounce four. The left-hander then scoops the next delivery over the wicketkeeper for another boundary.

47th over – Mid-on is up and Elgar’s lofted drive off Jimmy Anderson goes past him and runs away for four.

46th over – Attaboy Peterson! The left-hander pulls off two meaty reverse-sweeps for four and six off James Tredwell!

44th over – WICKET – Tredwell strikes again with another lovely piece of bowling. Wayne Parnell (5) steps out of his crease to try and a drive well-flighted delivery, but there is sharp turn away from the left-hander and Kieswetter completes another good stumping.

41st over – Off-spinner Tredwell returns but AB de Villiers greets him with an excellent reverse-paddle fine for four. WICKET – But three balls later, De Villiers comes down the pitch and tries to drive the ball inside-out over the covers. The delivery goes straight on, however, and Kieswetter pulls off a sharp stumping. De Villiers was going well on 39 off 46 balls, but has fatally underestimated Tredwell again.

29th over – WICKET – An awful shot by Faf du Plessis as he tries to run an in-swinger from Ravi Bopara, coming down the slope from the Pavilion End, to third man and only succeeds in dragging the ball back on to his stumps to be bowled for a single.

27th over – Bopara over-pitches and De Villiers drives him beautifully straight down the ground for four.

26th over – WICKET – JP Duminy has looked so good but again he’s thrown his wicket away at a crucial time! Duminy comes down the wicket to Tredwell, but the off-spinner has held the ball back a touch, the batsman is nowhere near the pitch and a bit of turn takes the ball past his attempt to push the ball on the leg side. Duminy is stumped by Craig Kieswetter for 18 off 22 balls.

25th over – WICKET – Hashim Amla is bowled as he misses a drive at a lovely little in-swinger from medium-pacer Bopara. Amla scored 45 off 73 balls, with only glimpses of his free-scoring best.

24th over – Amla missed out on the slog-sweep the ball before, but this time he hits it in the screws to collect four runs through square-leg off Tredwell.

22nd over – A beautiful shot by Duminy as he drives Dernbach through mid-on with wonderful timing for four.

21st over – Duminy squirts a drive off Anderson just past the diving Eoin Morgan at point and away for four runs.

20th over – WICKET – Dernbach surprises Smith with a quicker short delivery, the batsman edging an attempted hook through to wicketkeeper Kieswetter as he tried to play the ball above his shoulders and was late on the shot. Smith fought hard for his 29 off 54 balls.

18th over – Wow, what a shot by Amla as he drives pace bowler Dernbach straight over mid-off for a superb six!

17th over – Another dropped catch! Smith, on 26, drives hard at Steven Finn and gets the edge. But wicketkeeper Kieswetter dives across but misses the ball, putting off first slip Tredwell, who drops the catch again!

11th over – Another reprieve for Amla as Bopara jags a delivery back into the batsman, who is stuck in his crease and struck low on the pads. But umpire Richard Illingworth rules not out and Amla survives on 14. Hawkeye shows the ball would have hit the middle of leg stump, but England have already used up their review!

9th over – And now England have used their review as Amla misses a whip to leg off a Finn in-swinger and is struck in line with leg stump. But umpire Illingworth turns down the lbw appeal because, with the angle and Finn’s bounce, the ball is surely going over and past leg-stump. The review confirms this.

7th over – Finn drops short and Amla crunches a pull through midwicket for four.

5th over – A big let-off for South Africa as Amla, on four, drives off the back foot against Finn and the edge flies high, at an awkward height to Tredwell at second slip, who puts down the chance.

2nd over – And Amla also gets off the mark with a boundary, a beautifully controlled punch through extra cover off Anderson. It was actually a decent delivery with a bit of away movement.

1st over – A good start for South Africa as Finn’s second delivery, from over the wicket, is full, heading outside off stump and Smith plays it on length with a trademark clip through midwicket for a well-struck boundary.